1.
Magoza demonstrates bushido when he refuses to
tell the truth even though it put him in a situation where he could have died
or could have killed his best friend. This shows sell-sacrificing loyalty to
his master. Another time he demonstrates bushido is when he tells his master
that he would love to die by his side. This shows the importance of an
honorable death is samurai culture.
2.
The difference is that giri implies deep
personal connection. The book gives the examples of master-subordinate,
parent-child, and lovers. Obligations in American culture, however, can be
mundane and not personal. For example, I have an obligation to go to work, but
there is no personal connection between me and my employment.
3.
Bushido is based on a warrior’s code of conduct that
emphasizes loyalty and honor; whereas, giri involve personal relationships and obligation
to seek another person’s happiness. When Magoza agrees to raise the girl this
shows bushido because he is being obedient to his master. However, when he
waits till the girl consents to the marriage before arranging it, it is because
of giri (Magoza felt obligated to make the girl happy).
4.
The scene where Magoza finalizes the wedding
demonstrates how ie systems have reputations. It demonstrates this because Mahgoza
is scared that because the girl is born of a criminal the family would not want
that shame on their ie system. Another scene that shows how the ie system
worked is when Magoza first brings up the idea of Kane marrying the merchant
boy. Kane asks Magoza if she has a choice and the answer is no, she does not
have a choice. In the ie system the male head of the ie made all the decisions.
5.
This causes a contradiction about Kane’s
happiness. Kane knows that Magoza wants to make her happy and will make his decision
accordingly, but she will only be happy if she can choose her own love. But
Magoza believes that his decision to have her marry a merchant will make her
happy, therefore, she agrees to the marriage to make Magoza happy. This
conflict arose because of the power distribution in the ie system.
6.
American culture has traditionally favored men
in the family but this trend is changing and women are being treated more equally.
In my experience growing up men have always been treated better. When my mom
was with my dad he was in control of everything, my mom wasn’t even allowed to
check the mail. Then she met my now former stepdad and was treated better, but
he still had the final say in all matters. Therefore, in my experience men are
treated better and have more power in the family.
7.
Magoza’s wish was for Kane to marry a merchant.
Kane’s wish was to be with Magoza. Therefore, by setting up this marriage
Magoza was ignoring Kane’s wish.
8.
I think that in the end of this movie Magoza
will commit suicide. One reason I think this is because it is foreshadowed in
the movie by the numerous puppet show scenes that show people committing suicide.
In the book it says that (pg46) achieving an honorable death is important for the
samurai. Magoza was supposed to die an honorable death till he was assigned
this task, when he completes this task I think he will commit suicide since he
is supposed to already be dead.
9.
The puppet show was very much like Romeo and Juliet,
which I had to read in high school. In this play the moral is that young love
is the epitome of stupidity as evidenced by their dual suicide. I do not think
that the dual suicide in the puppet show has the same meaning.
No comments:
Post a Comment